When A Travel Rewards Card Is Worth It – And When It Isn’t

creditcardGenius Team
updated on Jun 24, 2021
Fact Checked
Fact Checked
Accuracy is important to us so this article has gone through a thorough 3-stage review process and fact-checked by our team.

Travel rewards cards can offer some serious savings and perks…

But are they right for you?

The quick answer is: it depends.

Factors to consider include:

  • how often you travel,
  • where you travel, and
  • what type of travel you do.

Knowing your spending habits is important, when deciding if a travel rewards card is worth it.

(And any credit card rewards you earn will be meaningless if you’re carrying a balance month to month, because typical credit card interest rates are insane. Focus on paying off that balance instead.)

Related: How to Get FREE Checked Bags When Flying

Never miss an amazing deal again + get our bonus 250+ page eBook for FREE. Join 50,000 other Canadians who receive our weekly newsletter – learn more.

When Travel Rewards Cards Are Worth It

In general, you should get a travel rewards card if:

  • You fly at least 1-2 times per year (for leisure or business).
  • You stay at hotels more than 5 days per year.
  • You rent cars frequently but do not currently have adequate insurance coverage.

Personally I tend to travel 1-2 times per year and have found it’s worth it for us to have a travel rewards card.

I use the WestJet RBC World Elite Mastercard for all travel rewards.

Related: WestJet RBC World Elite Mastercard: Deep Dive Review

The card has an annual fee of $119 but it also comes with an annual companion voucher which allows you to buy a second (companion) flight for a cheaper rate based on your destination ($99 for Canadian destinations).

The card also gives you (and anyone else travelling with you on the same itinerary) free checked bags on all Westjet flights. This is something that most people underestimate for savings.

If I travel round trip for a vacation I would typically save $50 per trip ($25 per flight), which turns into $100 savings if I travel with someone (usually the case).

The card costs $119 per year but the savings amount to around $600 per year so it’s obviously something that helps reduce our travel costs.

Even if you don’t travel often you may want to consider getting a travel rewards card for the travel perks offered by most premium travel cards. For example, the Scotiabank Gold American Express® Card has a full suite of travel insurance including:

  • Travel emergency medical coverage (including coverage for people over 65),
  • Travel Accident,
  • Trip Cancellation and Interruption,
  • Flight Delay,
  • Baggage Delay,
  • Lost or stolen baggage,
  • Hotel Burglary,
  • Rental Car theft and damage, and
  • Extended Warranty and purchase protection.

The BMO World Elite Mastercard is another great flexible travel rewards card that has 14 types of insurance coverage including coverage for all your personal items for the entire duration of your trip – that’s extremely rare.

Most travel rewards cards have a standard set of travel coverage similar to the ones listed above, and they all focus on ensuring you are covered when you travel.

Related: Credit Card Rental Insurance – How It Works

If you’re not a high spender but still want a travel card, then consider the MBNA Rewards Platinum Plus® Mastercard®. You’ll not only get a card that has no annual fee, but still has some pretty good earn rates:

  • 2 points for every $1 spent on restaurants, groceries, and select recurring bills (up to $10,000 spent annually per category)
  • 1 point per $1 spent on all other purchases

Each point is worth 1 cent, giving this card a minimum return of 1% on your spend. And best of all, you can use these points for any kind of travel you like. And, it also comes with seven different types of insurance. Pretty good for a no fee card.

Car rentals

A travel rewards card might be worth it if you rent a car for more than 5 days per year and don’t already have car rental insurance coverage, since the coverage is so expensive to purchase from the rental car company.

The car rental collision coverage came in handy for me once when I rented a car that was already damaged but somehow I forgot to check for damages before driving it off the lot (always do this and snap pictures to prove it!).

When I returned the car, I was told I was responsible for the damages since I didn’t report them…

The bill for the damages? It was around $1,000. An amount I would’ve had to pay if I didn’t pay for the rental with my credit card.

I could have made a claim through my own personal vehicle’s insurance, but it would have meant my rates possibly increasing in the future.

Making the claim through my credit card was relatively easy and the entire process was settled within a matter of weeks.

I was lucky I thought to pay for the car rental with my credit card and kept all receipts as well as documentation related to the claim itself.

I learned a relatively cheap lesson: Always pay for a rental car (the entire amount) using a credit card that has rental car coverage – and keep all receipts after the rental.

Related: Best US Dollar credit cards – if you have high-volume transactions in US dollars

When Travel Rewards Cards Aren’t Worth It

Travel rewards cards generally are NOT worth it if you travel or fly less than once a year. Because almost all travel rewards cards tend to focus on airlines/hotels.

If you travel in different ways such as camping, driving your own vehicle or using an AirBnB whenever you reach your destination…

Travel rewards card may not be for you, as they tend to focus on points for airlines or hotels. Although AirBnB is an eligible rewards for most flexible travel credit cards that allow you to pay for any travel related purchase that is charged to your card with points.

Also, many premium travel cards come with extensive travel insurance packages so if the coverage doesn’t apply to you, consider other types of credit cards.

Finally, travel rewards cards also aren’t worth it if you travel for business…but don’t have to pay for the expenses. The rewards come when YOU pay. So if your company pays on your behalf you should consider getting another type of card, since most premium travel cards have a fee of $100 or more per year.

Related: How To Maximize Your Tims Rewards

Alternative Card Options

If after weighing your options, it’s clear that a travel rewards card isn’t right for you…

There are other options available.

Consider a card that focuses on rewards for other categories.

Perhaps the simplest and transparent card category is one I’m a fan of: cash back cards.

Credit cards that offer cash back are very easy to understand and there is nothing better than getting cash back for the money you spend on the card. The cash back typically comes as an account credit annually which is the equivalent of a cash reward.

When searching for what card is right for you, the most important thing is to make sure you know what category you do most of your spending in.

Case in point, the Scotiabank Momentum Visa Infinite, here’s a review from a power user.

Someone who spends most of their money each month on groceries might want a different card than someone who spends most of their money at retail stores.

creditcardGenius is the only tool that compares 126+ features of 229 Canadian credit cards using math-based ratings and rankings that respond to your needs, instantly. Take our quiz and see which of Canada's 229 cards is for you.

Did you find this article helpful?
YesNo

Editorial Disclaimer: The content here reflects the author's opinion alone. No bank, credit card issuer, rewards program, or other entity has reviewed, approved, or endorsed this content. For complete and updated product information please visit the product issuer's website. Our credit card scores and rankings are based on our Rating Methodology that takes into account 126+ features for each of 229 Canadian credit cards.

Hot Credit Card Deals This Month

Hot Credit Card Deals This Month:

Comments


Leave a comment

Required fields are marked with *. Your email address will not be published.


Showing 5 comments

Gillian
Gillian
November 2, 2017
Interestingly, today my husband and I put in an online application for the NEW American Express Cobalt Card and everything went swimmingly until we had to call AMEX at the end of the application. We were told that yes we did indeed have great credit and there is no problem with our application but, as per Canadian laws, we had to go in person to the nearest AMEX office in Toronto. We live in the Burlington/Oakville area. Surely there could be another way for them to verify our legitimacy rather than having to take time off work and travel a few hours out of our day?! We were informed that some people can go to their closest post office but, with our postal code, we couldn't... and only had the option of travelling in to Toronto.
Pete
Pete
October 6, 2017
Any suggestions for a card to get to help with my yearly all inclusive holiday ? I have the TD aeroplan card ( FYF ) and am thinking of changing to a TD travel ( FYF ) . Good idea ? Bad idea ? Thanks
creditcardGenius Team
creditcardGenius Team
October 13, 2017
If you're looking for the best travel card on the market right now that will give you your first year free, the CIBC Aventura Visa Card. ( https://creditcardgenius.ca/credit-cards/cibc-aventura-visa-infinite ) This card has flexible rewards, a really nice sign up bonus, and a great travel insurance package that would definitely help with your yearly vacation. If you're hoping to stay with TD, however, the Areoplan cards from TD really are the best of the TD collection.
mARPY
mARPY
October 5, 2017
The problem that I find with travel reward cards is that when you use the points for travel (flights etc), they are no where near as lucrative as the 5 - 7% of spending that the card companies would like you to believe. with most plans, you have to pay the taxes and fly with specific airlines. When I look at what these airlines charge for flight that fly's when I want to fly. I can usually find a ticket for 1/3 of what they charge with another airline. As such, my 2% cash back card is IMO a far better deal. Because of what I have already stated, I value the points of these travel reward cards at 1/3 of what they claim. I also don't have to waist time and adjust my schedule to suit thier restrictions of using points. I have the flexability of flying with any airline I want and that meets my scheduling and flying criteria. I will take the cash back that I can spend any way I want over these travel points any day. JMO
Stephen Weyman
Stephen Weyman
October 5, 2017
When you're talking about Aeroplan, Avios, and other true airline mile rewards programs, I completely agree. Taxes & fees can be extra high and can erode your value. Availability can be limited and require being super flexible. There are good full value flights where you get that high 3%+ return on spending but it takes patience. I'm willing to work for it to save the extra money, some people aren't. However, with flexible travel or fixed points flights programs like American Express Membership Rewards fixed points, RBC Avion fixed points, Scotia Rewards it's different. When you book through their websites you get better availability than Aeroplan with more last minute booking options. You still may not see the entire inventory like you would on Expedia, but it's much better. If you look at flight numbers and compare the same flight on Expedia to what is available on American Express Membership Rewards (which I just did) the prices are $20-$30 apart and the taxes and fees are close too (about $20-$30 more). For Toronto to Vancouver on Air Canada in February it's showing $796.52 total fare on Expedia and $822.45 on Amex for an identical itinerary. Both sites list the base fare at $670. For 40,000 Membership Rewards points you can pay that full $670. Sure you're left over with $150 in taxes and fees, but that doesn't change the fact that you got $670 worth of value for those 40K points. That's a 1.68% return on spending if you're earning 1 point per dollar spent. With then new Amex Cobalt you get 5 points per dollar spent on groceries and restaurants. 5 x 1.68% is an 8.4% return on spending which blows my mind it's so good. Never seen rates like that before anywhere for economy flights. Yes, there were slightly cheaper routes listed on Expedia that weren't listed on Amex by about $150 (those early morning and late evening flights). But even if you take away that $150 and say you're only getting $520 in value, that's still 6.5% return on spending. No cash back card can match that. Or, you can just book the flight on Expedia, pay with the Cobalt card, and redeem it at a 1 cent per point value and you're still getting a 5% return on spending (grocery & restaurants) all taxes and fees covered too.
Koho Easy
What’s important to you?
Cash
Travel+
Low Fees
Insurance
Low Interest
Perks

creditcardGenius is a smart credit card matchmaker that compares 126+ features of 229+ credit cards, with objective ratings, rankings and reviews. Built in 2017, for Canadians by Canadians, creditcardGenius is trusted by more than 200,000 people every month, 50,000 newsletter subscribers, and 15M people since launch.

Read more about creditcardGenius

About creditcardGenius

creditcardGenius

The creditcardGenius team of writers is dedicated to bringing factual, helpful, and thorough information to Canadian consumers. Each piece of content goes through a 3-step review process because quality is important to us.

Read more about creditcardGenius Team

About creditcardGenius Team

creditcardGenius Team

Rating Methodology

The most comprehensive credit card rating system in Canada.

126+ total data points analyzed
Data point breakdown