Comparing PC Optimum vs. Scene+ rewards programs is tricky, but ultimately, Scene+ offers better value. Users can earn up to 1 cent per point with Scene+, while PC Optimum offers up to 0.21 cents per point.
These programs are more different than most people realize, but both do provide users opportunities to earn and redeem points when buying groceries. The Scene+ offers a larger variety of stores and spending options for earning points, but PC Optimum rewards Loblaws loyalists quite well.
To help you maximize your rewards potential, this article reviews both of these programs, including their unique perks and benefits. This should help you decide which program matches your spending and saving styles.
Key Takeaways
- Scene+ offers a consistent reward value of around 1 cent per point.
- PC Optimum point value is generally lower at 0.1 cents.
- Scene+ offers greater flexibility with earning and redeeming rewards, while PC Optimum is primarily a program for Loblaws shoppers.
- The best program for you depends on where you do most of your regular grocery shopping.
Never miss an amazing deal again + get our bonus 250+ page eBook for FREE. Join 50,000 other Canadians who receive our weekly newsletter – learn more.
Scene+ vs. PC Optimum at a glance
| Scene+ | PC Optimum | |
|---|---|---|
| What you earn | Scene+ points | PC points |
| Primary ways to earn points | * Sobeys * Safeway * Cineplex * Scene+ Travel * Recipe Unlimited Restaurants * Home Hardware * Shell gas stations * Credit cards | * Loblaws stores * Shoppers Drug Mart * No Frills * Esso gas stations * Credit cards |
| Average value of 1 point | 1 cent | 0.1 cents |
| Average Earn Rate | 1.00% | 1.00% |
| Best for | Travel, Groceries, Movie Tickets | Groceries and gas |
| How to redeem points at the grocery store | * 1,000 points for a $10 discount at the register at Sobeys and Safeway | * 10,000 points for a $10 discount at the register at Loblaws |
| What you can redeem points for | * Movie tickets and concessions * Travel * Groceries * Restaurants * Home Hardware * Merchandise * Gift cards * Shell fuel and convenience purchases * Statement credits | * Discounts at Loblaws * Esso fuel and car washes |
About Scene+
Scene+ originally started in 2007 as the Scene program, a partnership between Cineplex and Scotiabank. It was exclusively a program for redeeming tickets and concession fare at Cineplex theatres.
Then, in 2021, Scene and Scotia Rewards merged to form the Scene+ program. Suddenly, you could earn and use Scene points for travel, merchandise, and more. The following year, Sobeys joined the program.
In 2026, Scene+ welcomed Tangerine and Shell stations as partners. Tangerine introduced a Scene+ credit card, and Shell left Air Miles to reward Scene+ members with discounts and fuel rewards.
Here's how it works: You can earn (and in many cases, redeem) points for groceries, movies, travel through Expedia, Home Hardware purchases, online shopping, entertainment, restaurants, pharmacies, convenience stores, and gift cards. Then, redeem your points for discounts with select retailers.
About PC Optimum
PC Optimum is a partnership rewards program launched by Loblaws in 2013. 5 years later, the program merged with Shoppers Optimum to form PC Optimum. As you might guess, you earn points for spending at Loblaws, Shoppers, Esso gas stations, and partnering stores (and by using a PC Financial credit card).
You can use your PC points for discounted gas and free car washes at Esso stations or get discounts at participating stores.
How it works: Join the program and earn points for groceries, fuel purchases, and car washes at Esso. Take advantage of promotional opportunities to earn bonus points. Then, when you're ready to redeem, put your points toward free car washes, store discounts, fuel discounts, charitable donations, or a discount toward the PC credit card annual fee.
Best return on rewards: PC Optimum
Canada's 2 largest grocery retailers offer similar rewards on grocery purchases. At Loblaws and Sobeys stores, the only way to earn points while shopping is through personalized offers and on-sale items.
To see how the savings compare to Scene+, we took a fairly standard grocery list, added up the costs and rewards we earned, and calculated the total return on our spending.
Take a look at our Sobeys/Safeway shopping list:
| Item | Price | Points Earned |
|---|---|---|
| Folgers Coffee | $11 | 150 |
| Persil Laundry Detergent | $19 | 150 |
| Almond Milk | $4.49 | 50 |
| Lysol Wipes | $3.49 | 50 |
| Total | $37.99 | 400 |
We've earned 400 points, which are worth $4.
Our return on these 4 items? Just a pinch over 10%.
Compare that to our Loblaws list:
| Item | Price | Points Earned |
|---|---|---|
| Mushrooms | $3 | 600 |
| Cheese | $10 | 1,200 |
| Pork | $6.20 | 1,200 |
| Crackers | $6 | 1,200 |
| Raspberries | $5 | 1,000 |
| Knorr Sidekicks | $6 | 1,200 |
| Atlantic Butter | $7 | 600 |
| Hot Dogs | $6 | 400 |
| Baking Soda | $1.20 | 200 |
| Total | $50.40 | 7,600 |
We've earned a total of 7,600 points, which is worth $7.60.
Our return across all items is 15.1%.
We have to give the winner's trophy to PC Optimum. At this time, it seems like PC Optimum has a better handle on personalized offers, so we get more value from the program.
Best earning opportunities: Scene+
If you have to choose just one loyalty program based on where you can earn points, we'd have to recommend Scene+. Whether you're shopping online, catching a movie, picking up groceries, eating out, or doing a home renovation project, you can earn points each step of the way.
Scene+ earning opportunities:
| Where you earn | What you earn |
|---|---|
| Rakuten online shopping platform | Up to 20% back |
| Partnering grocery stores (Safeway, Sobeys, Foodland, IGA, Thrifty Foods, and more) | Personalized rewards and offers |
| Cineplex movie theatres | * 3 points per $1 spent on regular tickets and concessions * 6 points per $1 spent on premium tickets |
| Expedia via Scene+ portal | 3 points per $1 spent on hotels and car rentals |
| Home Hardware in-store and online | 50 points for every $50 spent |
| Rec Room and Playdium | 1 point per $1 spent on food, drinks, games, and entertainment |
| Dining (700+ restaurants, including Harvey's, Kelsey's Original Roadhouse, and Montana's BBQ & Bar) | 1 point for every $3 spent |
| Shell gas stations | * 1 point per litre of fuel * 1 point per $1 spent on convenience purchases * 1 point per $1 spent on car washes |
| Use a Scotiabank debit card | 1 point per $1 spent |
| Use a Scotiabank credit card | 1.5% to 6% back (depending on your card's terms) |
By comparison, you're pretty limited with PC Optimum, only earning points on specific deals or offers at Loblaws Banner stores, at Shoppers, or at Esso stations.
PC Optimum earning opportunities:
| Where you earn | What you earn |
|---|---|
| Loblaws banner stores | Only earn on personalized offers or in-store deals |
| Esso and Mobil gas stations | 10 points per $1 spent or per litre |
| Home Health Care, Pharmaprix, and Shoppers Drug Mart | 15 points per $1 spent |
| PC Financial credit card | * 10 to 40 points per $1 spent at Loblaws * 25 to 50 points per $1 spent at Shoppers * 30 to 50 points per litre at Esso |
| PC Money Account | * 150,000 points for opening the account and setting up direct deposits (terms and conditions apply) * 10 points per $1 spent at Loblaws * 25 points per $1 spent at Shoppers * 5 points per $1 spent everywhere else |
Best redemption options: Scene+
The best Scene+ redemptions are worth up to 1 cent per point (CPP), while the best PC Optimum redemptions are worth 0.21 CPP.
To determine this value, we reviewed every redemption option and calculated values by CPP. We divided the reward cost by its cost in points, then multiplied by 100 to get the CPP.
Scene+ redemption options:
| Redemption option | Point value |
|---|---|
| $10 off groceries at Safeway, Sobeys, Foodland and more | 1 CPP |
| Cash back at Cineplex, Rec Room, and Playdium | 1 CPP |
| Cash back at Scene+ Travel and Shell gas stations | 1 CPP |
| Cash back at Home Hardware | 1 CPP |
| Cash back at over 700 restaurants | 1 CPP |
| Gift cards | 0.71 – 1 CPP |
| Points for credit | 0.67 – 0.71 CPP |
PC Optimum redemption options:
| Redemption option | Point value |
|---|---|
| Car wash at Esso or Mobil | 0.21 CPP |
| $10 cash back at Loblaws, Shoppers, Real Canadian Superstore, and more | 0.1 CPP |
| Fuel discount at Esso or Mobil | 0.1 CPP |
| Donate points to charity | 0.1 CPP |
What do shoppers say?
Although Scene+ offers better value over PC Optimum, what matters to everyday users is how these programs offer personal value and convenience. With just a brief search, we found that Reddit users have both good and bad things to say about PC Optimum, while the comments about Scene+ are almost all negative.
As an example, this Redditor is obviously unhappy with the PC Optimum program:
These users, however, comment that they got excellent value from their PC Optimum redemptions:
Looking at the Scene+ program, these users aren't impressed with how the program works at grocery stores:
We found many posts complaining about the Scene+ mobile app. In this example, several people responded to a post titled "Is the Scene+ app embarrassingly bad or is it just mine?":
At least one user appreciates the Scene+ program, though:
To sum it up, people are divided about both rewards programs. This proves, once again, that the best program is the one that best suits your spending and is most convenient for you to navigate.
FAQ
How do Scene+ vs. PC Optimum points compare?
Although both programs earn rewards for things like grocery purchases, the partners are completely different, and the redemption options vary wildly. PC Optimum points are really best for in-store discounts and free car washes, while Scene+ gives more value for store and fuel discounts, travel, gift cards, and financial products.
How much are 20,000 points worth at Shoppers?
If you're redeeming 20,000 PC Optimum points at Shoppers Drug Mart, you'll get $20 off your store purchase. For better value, you could redeem those points for $30 worth of car washes at Esso stations. You can use our convenient PC Optimum points calculator to determine the value of your own points for different redemption options.
Is Scene+ better than Air Miles?
Again, it ultimately depends on how you earn rewards. Air Miles – now Blue Rewards – can be a better travel rewards program if you redeem your miles strategically. These rewards also hold better value than Scene+ points, but you might find it easier to accumulate Scene+ rewards.
How much money are 1,000 Scene points worth?
Using our Scene+ calculator, we can see you'll get $10 in value if you put your 1,000 Scene+ points toward the in-store discounts with partners, or any travel if you're a Scene+ cardholder. Avoid using your points for gift cards, as they offer the lowest return on investment.
Which is the best loyalty program in Canada?
If you're strictly looking at the best average earn rate, McDonald's Rewards actually comes out on top at 12.6% – almost double that of the second-place program, VIPorter. That said, the best loyalty program in Canada is the one that aligns with your spending and rewards style.
Is Scene+ free?
Yes, Scene+ is free for anyone to join, but you must be over 14 years old to be eligible for the program. Since Scene+ rewards entertainment, restaurant, and travel purchases, it's an excellent rewards program for teens and young adults.
creditcardGenius is the only tool that compares 126+ features of 243 Canadian credit cards using math-based ratings and rankings that respond to your needs, instantly. Take our quiz and see which of Canada's 243 cards is for you.
GC: 
Comments
Leave a comment
Required fields are marked with *. Your email address will not be published.
Showing 1 comments